Wednesday, July 4, 2007

Fighting Militant Islam

I'm currently reading a great book called The Secret History of the Iraq War by Yossef Bodansky. It's an incredibly authoritative and detailed account of the preparation for and conduct of the Iraq War, to include Saddam's support of Islamic terrorist organizations and his WMD programs.

As I've been reading it, I've been thinking about my previous post about the Apaches and Al Qaeda. It's true that our current strategy of killing terrorist leaders is not working. Computer simulations have shown it is not a viable strategy against decentralized organizations, and real-world studies have born out the same. I made the comment that the solution probably exists in the non-military realm, which, if I were to say such a thing aloud at work, would make me a virtual parriah, a left-wing nutball. It's bad enough I'm an environmentalist animal-lover. (Which is very weird, since in my family, I am the RIGHT-wing nutball.)

But long-term, I'm skeptical there's anything we can do but to continue killing as many militant Muslims as we can, while trying to cut off their funding and deny them refuge anywhere in the world.

I was reminded of a couple of crucial things in this book that neither I, nor anyone else, should ever forget.

1. Militant Muslims have claimed again and again that they will not rest until we are destroyed. Not until we've left Iraq. Not until we're friendly with other nations. Not until we stop helping Israel. Until we are DESTROYED. Until, "The flag of Islam flies over the White House," as more than one terrorist has put it.

2. There is no concept of peace, coexistence, truce, or anything other than war in the religion of Islam. The phrase, "Religion of Peace" is a joke. They didn't conquer northern Africa, Spain, Indonesia, etc by being peaceful. You'll never hear them claim the "Religion of Peace" when they are in power. They will seek a truce when they are weak, and fight again when they are strong. Mohamud once made a 10 year truce with his enemies, and broke it 2 years later when his armies were strong, and now all Muslims believe it is thier duty to do the same. When you hear Muslims seeking a truce or peace and calling theirs the "Religion of Peace," it is simply a ruse to buy time until they are strong again. When Usama bin Laden was on the run early in the war, he made a tape seeking a truce. Once he was safe, he started calling for attacks again. And if you read their literature, they are waiting until there is a Democrat in the White House until they strike again. They know if they strike the US now, we will fight.

So what do you do against such an enemy? There is no politically correct solution. There is no humane way of dealing with them. There is no way of making peace and going home. We can't turn our backs on them. What's hardest to grasp is that it is not just a handful of terrorists that are the problem. All Muslims believe the world belongs to Islam, and everyone else should be killed or converted. That's not an extremist point of view, but rather a central part of their religious teachings.

In the lead up to the Iraq War, Iran, Syria, Iraq, and others conspired to instigate Isreal into entering the war in order to draw other Arab nations into it as well, to include using various WMDs. Saddam figured it was the only way to stay in power. What's really scary, is that they almost succeeded. We came incredbly close to WW III, certainly closer than the Bay of Pigs, and I think it's only a matter of time before it erupts. I just hope the Western world wakes up and takes this fight seriously.

8 comments:

Stephanie said...

If you like that book, I'll send you Why I left Jihad by Walid Shoebat. He was a member of the PLO and had personally killed or had taken part in planning the murders of several Israelis, participated in numerous violent demonstrations and also provided support to a multitude of terrorist operations. He fell in love with a Christian and in his attempt to convert her by proving her wrong, realized he had been lied to about pretty much everything about Israel and the west in the mosque while growing up. He is also a great speaker and has made it his life mission to speak to as many Americans as he can about the truth about Islam and its teachings. The thing he finds most frustrating is that they tell us exactly what they want to accomplish (which is what you outlined), and the majority of us in the west still don't believe them.

By the way, the "religion of peace" has issued a fatwa for his head, he is a hunted man, who travels with several body guards even to go to the store, and you have to go through some hoops to find out where he'll be speaking.

Keep up the great work! Love you.

swxdebhlbl2a@q

mom & dad said...

Hi Josh - I agree with what you are saying, but it is very disheartening isn't it? They have a very different, in-grained mind set from us and we have a hard time understanding them. I don't see that war will be the answer but I don't know what will work. I have always hoped there were those smarter than me figuring these things out, but that is not true is it? Well, I am always interested in your ideas - they are well thought out and you have a way of writing that even I understand.

Talked to Stephanie & Zach last night! I can't wait to see them later this month- I know Zach has changed so much I won't recognize him! Good hearing from you. We love you - mom & dad

Josh Kaminoff said...

As Steph pointed out, a lot of what they hate about us is terribly misinformed. They tend to see the worst in all our actions, and none of the good things we do end up in their newspapers or on their radios (of course, very little ends up in ours either). I had hoped that a campaign designed to spread the truth about us would help quell some of the hatred, but any attempt to tell them something other than what they've been taught is seen as propaganda and disinformation. They refuse to believe we want only peace, prosperity, and freedom for everyone.

Personally, I feel their distrust and hatred for us is nothing more than them projecting their own untrustworthy, deceitful, and, for a lack of a beter word, evil character on their enemies. They really are sneaky bastards, to put it nicely, and they can't help but see everyone else the same way.

Anonymous said...

Hi Josh. Gino here. Gary passed me the link to your blog. Just wanted to say hope all is going well for you and hopefully you're staying clear of the boutiful Baskin Robbins over at the DFAC!!! God knows I got carried away with that stuff. Take care and say safe!!

Josh Kaminoff said...

Hey Gino, how's life in the 'FIS? I heard you got some interns in.
Work is cool. Apparently, I'm the only one who knows anything about Analyst's Notebook, so I'm trying to show them how it's done.
I learned my lesson from last time wrt the DFAC. I'm eating as much fruit and vegetables as I can, and NO ICE CREAM. I just wish I had more time to run and work out. I'm trying to get Psi up on my machine so I can use you guys as reachback, so keep a look out. Later.

Anonymous said...

Josh,

Life in the 'FIS is good. Been really busy w/the DAO course. I just got back from Korea doing the Project Morning Calm thing. Gary and Dave say hello as well.
No problem with the reachback thing. I'd be more than happy to help with anything if you need it. I'll look for you on PSI.

Be safe.

G

kathyjh said...

hi, josh

glad you made it safe and sound and feel good about the surroundings and all.

interesting book review. we certainly have some commonality with islam as a 'peace' religion since christianity has been responsible- directly or indirectly- for a good number of wars and uprisings over the ages.

i find your thinking about non-military solutions provocative. what if we went at it from the perspective of making those outside the militant groups less interested in what they are doing? it seems like we could do a good deal along the lines of fighting disease, hunger and poverty on a wider scale. populations suffering under these scourges are more prone to being bent by extremist groups.

good luck with the job and the exercising. i once knew of a doc who spent his lunch hour on an exercise bike reading the newspaper. talk about multi-tasking.

take care and be safe!

Josh Kaminoff said...

One non-miltary solution that I'm quite sure would make a difference (though surely would not win us the war) is help Arab nations provide alternatives to militant Islam among young adults.

In many third-world countries, if a young male feels idealogically motivated to make a difference in his community, culture, or country, often his only choice is to become a terrorist and fight the forces he sees as being responsible for his problems.

There is no Peace Corps to join, or Habitat for Humanity. There are no volunteer programs to make someone feel they are making a difference. There may be jobs or educational opportunities, but these mean little to someone idealogically motivated.

We could try to provide alternatives ourselves, but they would just be seen as tools of some Zionist plot. Arab nations and communities need to do this themselves, though many Muslim countries encourage militant Islam and use it for their own ends.

The countries that have the most to fear from militant Islam, like Saudi Arabia, should be helped with this kind of work.

Best case scenario, though, is there would be slightly fewer dedicated professionals trying to kill us.